Mid-depth is a privilege, not a rule
Every formula in this chapter measures from the neutral axis, and in elastic bending the neutral axis passes through the centroid of the cross-section. On a rectangle or a symmetric I-shape that is mid-depth, and nobody has to think about it. Weld a cover plate on one flange, or build a tee, and the symmetry is gone. The axis moves toward the heavier side, and it has to be found before anything else can be trusted.
For a section made of two parts: , read aloud y-bar equals A-one y-one plus A-two y-two, all over A-one plus A-two. Name the letters once. and are the areas of the two parts in mm²; the subscripts only say which part, 1 or 2, and you choose the numbering. and are the heights of each part's OWN centroid above a datum, in mm. The datum is any reference line you like, and the underside of the section is the usual choice. , said y-bar, is the height of the whole section's centroid above that same datum, in mm, and it is the one you are solving for.
Read it as what it is: an area-weighted average. A plain average of the two heights would be right only if the parts were the same size. They rarely are, so the bigger part gets the bigger say, and always lands between and , nearer the larger area. If your answer falls outside that range, stop. An average cannot escape the numbers it averages.
Two slips cost the marks here. The first is a mixed datum: every height in the sum must start from the SAME line, so a flange sitting on a 150 mm stem has its centre at 150 plus half its own thickness, not at half its thickness. The second is stopping too soon. Once is known, the distance to the extreme fibre is measured from it, and on a lopsided section the two faces are no longer the same distance away. The face FURTHER from the centroid governs the stress. Units guide, they do not confess: mm² times mm over mm² is mm, which is necessary and proves nothing more.
- = Centroid of the whole section from the datum (length)
- = Area of part 1 (area)
- = Centroid of part 1 from the datum (length)
- = Area of part 2 (area)
- = Centroid of part 2 from the datum (length)