Applied Field Engineering · Time on the trail
Naismith's rule, and what it is honest about
score 0

Naismith's rule, and what it is honest about

William Naismith was a Scottish mountaineer, and in 1892 he wrote down the sentence that still plans hill days: allow an hour for every three miles on the map, plus an hour for every 2,000 feet of ascent. The metric habit rounds it to t=d5+h600t = \dfrac{d}{5} + \dfrac{h}{600}t equals d over five, plus h over six hundred.

The letters: tt is the walking time in hours; dd is the route distance in kilometres, measured on the map; hh is the total ascent in metres. The 5 and the 600 are not adjustable parameters — they ARE the rule. Change them and it is somebody else's rule with Naismith's name on it. Note also that hh is ascent only: descent is not credited, and the basic rule has no negative climb.

Carry it in a form you can use while walking: 12 minutes per kilometre, plus 6 minutes per 60 m of climb. The classic sanity check is 10 km on the flat coming out at almost exactly 2 hours — if your own answer surprises you, the units on dd and hh are the first place to look.

The other half of this lesson is the version with no assumptions in it: t=dVgt = \dfrac{d}{V_g}, time equals distance over the speed made good. VgV_g is what the party actually achieved over the ground, tussocks and stops and all — not the speed the legs think they are doing. This is trivial arithmetic and it is the single most common place a plan goes wrong, because the number people put into the denominator is so often an aspiration.

Now the honesty, and it is the whole point. Naismith assumed a fit walker, unladen, on decent ground, in daylight. Load, bog, navigation stops, a river crossing, tired legs and a gauge that will not reset all stretch the figure and none of them shrink it. Tranter's corrections are the standard extension when the estimate has to survive contact with a real hill. Treat Naismith as a floor: if the floor already runs past last light, no amount of pressing on will fix it.